Should You Ditch Your Medicare Advantage Plan? Most People Do
Remember that time you found what looked like the perfect spot for dinner, maybe a new restaurant with a great “early bird special” sign out front? You were excited, envisioning a delightful meal without breaking the bank. But then the food took forever, the waiter was hard to find, and your favorite item wasn’t even on the menu. Sound familiar? Sometimes, what seems like a great deal on the surface doesn’t quite live up to expectations when it comes to the actual experience.
That feeling can ring true for some folks navigating Medicare, especially with Medicare Advantage (Part C) plans. These plans, offered by private insurers, have become increasingly popular, often marketed with alluring “zero premium” offers and clear out-of-pocket limits. They’re essentially an alternative to Original Medicare (Parts A and B, and often D for prescription drugs), like choosing a pre-set tasting menu instead of ordering à la carte. But as many as half of those who sign up for Advantage plans end up switching within five years, a statistic that makes you wonder what’s really cooking.
Why Folks Are Trading In Their “Restaurant” Reservations
It turns out, the reasons people switch out of their Medicare Advantage plans aren’t usually about the “price of the meal” itself. Research highlighted by , drawing from the Medicare Current Beneficiary Survey, points to two big factors: difficulty accessing care and concerns about the quality of the care received. It’s like finding yourself at that restaurant where the host is perpetually busy and the chef’s specials just aren’t hitting the mark.
For those with ongoing health needs, these access and quality issues are even more pronounced. The study found that individuals describing themselves in poor health were:
- More than twice as likely to have difficulty getting care.
- More than three times as likely to be dissatisfied with care quality.
- More than twice as likely to be unhappy with specialty care.
This often leads people not just to another Advantage plan, but to switch back to traditional Original Medicare, which offers broader access to doctors and hospitals without the same network restrictions.
How to Find the Right “Menu” for Your Health
So, if you’re exploring your options, how do you make sure you pick a “restaurant” (or plan) that truly serves your needs, not just your wallet? It’s about doing your homework before you’re starving.
First, inspect the menu and the kitchen staff. That means visiting the Advantage plan’s website to check their searchable directory. You need to verify if your trusted doctor, your favorite specialist, and the hospital you prefer are all part of the plan’s network. Don’t assume. Just like you’d check if your favorite pasta dish is on the menu, confirm your preferred care providers are covered.
Next, read the reviews. The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) publish Star Ratings on the Medicare Plan Finder. These ratings are like universal Yelp reviews for health plans, offering a glimpse into others’ satisfaction with the service and quality. Plans with low star ratings are, predictably, more likely to lead to dissatisfaction and future switching, so pay attention to what others are saying.
Finally, know your reservation windows. The Medicare Advantage open enrollment period runs from January 1 to March 31 each year. Original Medicare’s open enrollment is from October 15 to December 7. These aren’t just suggestions, they’re firm deadlines. Doing your research early, before these periods, ensures you have ample time to make an informed decision, rather than rushing to pick the first “zero-premium” sign you see. It’s all about optimizing your health, not gambling on it.
Ready to chat?
Book your free consultation now
Book a Call With Scott.This material is for informational purposes only and is not intended as individualized tax or investment advice. Consult your own tax, legal, or financial professional before making any decisions. Past performance is no guarantee of future results.
